March 22nd, 2010

Caravaggio?

  • I am trying to identify a painting. Around 1988 or 1989, I visited the Uffizi museum in Florence, Italy. My memory is somewhat fuzzy, but I know that I saw a painting of a (I think) reclining woman with a baby. My strong recollection is that this painting was a Caravaggio. I've looked on the Uffizi web site. It is not listed. (At least not under Caravaggio.) The painting was striking because of the expression on the face of the baby or toddler. Odd though it may sound, "lascivious" would not be far off in describing the child's expression. I've been searching Caravaggio web sites and cannot find this painting. Is my age getting to me? Have I got the artist wrong? Another problem is that, while I know that this painting was depicting specific individuals, I cannot say who they were. Eros and Aphrodite? Madonna and child? I just don't know. Anyway, I am hoping that this will ring a bell with someone. I would also appreciate a link to a site with this painting. Thanks.


  • What about this? http://www.artchive.com/artchive/T/titian/titian_partridge.jpg.html markj-ga


  • Hello You may want to search this website for your painting. Just enter "mother and child" in the search box. Good luck, C.


  • Please, forgive me, alexandraroman, but your question aroused a lot of questioning inside myself and I'd like to introduce myself and, after, ask for pinkfreud's opinion: I'm in Brazil. I love art and I'm a searching fanatic, probably because my sun sign is Scorpio, that astrologers say are fit for research. Also, because I speak Portuguese (a latin language) for me it is easy to search web pages written in French, Spanish and Italian. Your question interested me but I wasn't able to find any answer. And I found terrific the way marie4 had the insight (or luck or hard work) on what you were looking for (because what is really hard is to search for something that even the askers don't know much about it or what they're really looking for) and more terrific was the way you recognized her effort and kindness, because as pinkfreud stated marie4 is not a clickable blue lighted answerer. Now, for pinkfreud, and I hope he/she sees this comment (and that's what my questioning is all about): I'm not a google answer researcher, but maybe a few times I got it right. These following two are questions I have answered and I got a feedback from the asker: http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=356268 http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=391825 These two I'm quite sure I have found the answer but I don't have any way to know even if the asker read my comment: http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=388852 http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=304656 And this quetion, in which I helped and the value the ga researcher added to my help was to translate the pages and give information on the painter's (probably) major interest that is playing chess, and receive $50. http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=394076 So, pinkfreud, as one of the most active ga reseachers, don't you think that assertive commenters should, for the least, get their effort recognized in any way? Probably, a way of rewarding correct answers for expired questions, giving the chance for gar's to try to answer it. Or, as I said, a recognition that the efforts were not in vain. For you, garesearchers, it is easy to get a feedback because the asker is charged for the answer. We, not gar's, can not apply to be one of you (admissions closed), and, I'm sure, Google Answers, like Google, will be everywhere and in every language. So, that's my questioning, and it will continue because I don't know if pinkfreud will read this comment. Thanks, alexandraroman luntes


  • To: markj-ga No, it's not the Titian. Very different style. And the Titian baby looks more horrified than anything. The baby I'm thinking of looked more like a pint-sized version of Caravaggio's Bacchus. Of course, it was a long time ago... But thanks anyway!


  • >> So, pinkfreud, as one of the most active ga reseachers, >> don't you think that assertive commenters should, for the >> least, get their effort recognized in any way? When I first arrived at Google Answers, the doors were closed to new Researchers. After a few months, during which I posted several hundred comments which I hope were useful, I was brought into consideration as a potential Google Answers Researcher; I was accepted, and became a full-fledged GAR. At least two of my colleagues have become GARs by the same route. It is my sincere hope that the efforts of our more insightful commenters will be noticed by the Google Answers staff, and that the best of the commenters will be given the opportunity to become Researchers, if they so desire. Unfortunately, the decision is not mine. ~pinkfreud


  • To marie4-ga: You know, I've reached the conclusion that you have the answer. What finally decided me was that I was able, armed with artist name (Annibale Carracci)you provided, to check out the Uffizi web site more profitably. (Of course, I should have thought of going by rooms to begin with.) It seems that the painting by Annibale Carracci hangs in room 43 of the Uffizi. This room is called the Caravaggio room. It contains two works by Caravaggio. One is the Bacchus painting. It also contains Venus with a Satyr and Cupids by Carracci. Memory is a strange thing. I must have viewed the two paintings within seconds of each other & somehow conflated the experiences. Then there is the name of the room too. So, thanks very much. I am contacting the powers that be at google answers to let them know that I consider you to have answered my question.


  • To marie4-ga: Honestly, I don't think that this is it, although I'm starting to doubt my memory. It is a LOT closer, though. It's so close that maybe I'm wrong. My memory (unreliable) is that the baby figure was toward the right of the painting with the woman more to the left. But, again, I'm starting to doubt myself. Thanks a lot.


  • To marie4-ga: The powers that be inform me that there is no charge for your comment. Since you've answered my question with your comment, I don't see why you shouldn't receive the fee (small though it is). Please feel free to post your comment as an answer & I'll put through the payment.


  • alexandraroman-ga, The comment by marie4-ga cannot be posted as an answer, since marie4-ga is not a Google Answers Researcher. One of the most interesting features of Google Answers is that sometimes you may receive information free of charge from a helpful site user. If you consider the question answered, you may want to cancel it (click the grey button that says "Cancel Question"). To tell Google Answers Researchers from other users, examine the way the username is displayed. A Google Answer Researcher's username is highlighted in blue and is "clickable." All other usernames are standard bold text.


  • Excuse me again, alexandraroman, for invading your space, but this is again for pinkfreud: Thanks, pinkfreud. I admire you. What I think is unfair is that you, GARs get instant feedback, maybe because money is involved?, and we, not GARs, don't get the same feedback. If comments are free and don't have the same status of an answer, who knows expired answers would be a great way to screen insightable reseachers that get there, that find what GARs didn't. I believe you may have access and be listened by GA staff, so, if you think it is something to consider, ask them to carefully analyse comments and think about answering expired questions as a way to improve business and to improve relationship with potential GAs, and also, as is my case, to think of Brazil's "Google Responde" (I believe the staff has already thought of that)and not to forget me when it becomes true. Thanks, alexandraroman and pinkfreud. luntes


  • luntes, It is very flattering to be thought influential, but I have no special status and no inside access to the GA staff. I have never met a Google Answers Editor in person; I know none of their names, and I doubt that they know mine. I am, like all the other Researchers, a contractor, not an employee of Google. The policies of Google Answers are not set by Google Answers Researchers, and we GARs do not have knowledge of policy decisions until after the decisions have been made. ~pinkfreud


  • Prefer the words cupid, venus, cupidon, aphrodite,... This one? http://gallery.euroweb.hu/html/c/carracci/annibale/1/venus_sc.html







  • #If you have any other info about this subject , Please add it free.#
    Your name:
    E-mail:
    Telphone:

    Your comments:


    If you have any other info about Caravaggio? , Please add it free.